I made this cake back in November last year for my then boyfriends 28th birthday. He had mentioned casually that he would like a guitar cake but was really just joking. I took him seriously and below is a bit of a tutorial on how I actually got from thinking about making a cake to eating it!
How to make a cake!
Not just anycake… but the most awesome of all cakes!
A Guitar Hero II cake!
1. Freak out for about a month about how crazy you were to consider making the cake. Spend hours googling “decorating cakes”, “cake fillings” and “OMG AM I CRAZY”
2. Pick up bits and pieces for making the cake over the course of the month… spending over $100 just on “stuff”.

3. Cut out templates for the cake and start making the “extra” pieces by rolling out coloured icing and cutting to size. put these in an airtight container to harden.


4. Order the sheet cake from a bakery that doesnt know what you’re talking about so you have to speak to three people before they understand.

5. Look at the sheet cake and wonder how you will cut the pieces out, use wax paper to make templates (make sure you have right side up and wrong side up layers so you have a flat surface on the top) and then cut! put all the cut off pieces of cake in a bowl to snack on.



6. Cut cake board to fit into box that the actual guitar came in. put cake in box and go to bed.

7. Go to work, freak out some more about how this is all going to come together since you’re going to a gig and have a house guest for the weekend.
8. Before the gig, start making icing (white chocolate butter cream), filling (dark chocolate ganache) and drinking wine (brown brothers, dolchetto and syrah). the wine will relax you some what and make the nerves go away for an hour or so.

9. Put icing on the cake board and lay the first layer on the board with the right side up. you do not want the cake sliding off when you move it around.
10. Once the filling has cooled in the freezer to make it solid enough to spread without running down the edges cover the first layer liberally. dont go to close to the edges (it will discolour the outer icing if it bleeds out).


11. Stand back and marvel at the first layer being complete. then put the top layer on (right side down, so that the flat bottom of the cake is your flat top surface). wow! it looks like a guitar.

12. Brush away all the crumbs from the cake and using the icing which has also been cooled in the freezer cover entire cake in a thin layer. this is to seal in the crumbs as well as adding some moisture.

13. Now its time to get rolling! kneed the fondant icing till it is softened and then roll out, using the wax paper template to check the size. dont forget you need overhang to cover the sides.

14. FREAK OUT about how to get the massive flat icing onto the cake, request assistance from the “only hours to go till my birthday” boy.
15. Lay the icing flat on the cake and gently pull the sheet back without stretching the icing. Smooth the corners and press the icing to the cake firmly but not roughly. use a fondant smoother to remove finger marks and any weird lines. cut the excess icing from the board and press the icing under the cake, smoothing as you go.

16. Stand back and marvel some more at the icing being half way complete.

17. Kneed the black icing with 1/3 white icing to get a better consistancy to work with (it doesnt ruin the colour at all! thats how much colour is in the icing!) and cover the already covered cake with cling film to ensure you don’t stain it with the black icing.
18. Roll out the black icing, lay on cake and shape as for the white icing.

19. Stand back and let the “only hours to go till my birthday” boy rock out to the awesomeness that is the cake. put the cake away in its box and go see YOU AM I!

20. Wake up late the next day and then nap on the couch till about 11.30 then have people come over that cant see the cake before the party. wonder when you’ll be able to finish decorating cake. enjoy having people over anyway!
21. Once person that cant see the cake is gone, bend cable knitting needle to make wahwah wand and put icing on end to harden. cut out details from the hardened flats of icing you make earlier. put together on cake with royal icing.


22. Drizzle royal icing on the back of edging ribbon and press to the bottom edge of cake. hide joins in the join of icing.

23. Stand back and marvel in amazement at the finished cake!

24. Go to party, put candles in the cake, get proposed to then cut up cake and eat! ENJOY!

The entire set of photos are in my flickr.
edit: yes, i said yes!

28 responses so far ↓
Nikki // August 7, 2008 at 2:30 pm |
That is one fabulous cake!!! Oh and Congrats!
Liz // August 8, 2008 at 4:47 am |
Looks like something straight out of Charm City Cakes!
I love the fun instructions (although I’m sure they weren’t as fun when you were actually making the cake).
And Congratulations!
Think Think… » Blog Archive » HOW TO - Bake a Guitar Hero Cake // August 8, 2008 at 8:41 am |
[...] Hosting RSS Feed Killing Boredom… I’m Not Charming shows you how to bake a Guitar Hero cake. Thanks [...]
Piroksa // August 8, 2008 at 9:46 am |
Wow, that is amazing! I think my boyfriend would propose to me too if I made such a fantastic cake. Congratulations!
Paisley Cupcakes » Blog Archive » Make your own Guitar Hero cake // August 8, 2008 at 11:34 pm |
[...] Not Charming provides us with an eloquent (and playful) tutorial on how to make the Guitar Hero cake of our loved one’s [...]
Noteu » Guitar Hero Birthday Party // August 9, 2008 at 3:34 am |
[...] com este Guitar Hero Cake. Parece complicadíssimo. Eu também acho, mas você pode tentar este tutorial (em inglês, foi [...]
Be a Cake Hero | Wii Crazed // August 11, 2008 at 4:58 am |
[...] maker a marriage proposal, but soon after, not all cakes are a Guitar Hero homage. Charm White made this cake last fall for her then-boyfriend’s birthday, but didn’t manage to get around to talking [...]
Be a Cake Hero | Killer Wii Deals // August 11, 2008 at 5:33 am |
[...] the maker a marriage proposal, but then, not all cakes are a Guitar Hero homage. Charm White made this cake last fall for her then-boyfriend’s birthday, but didn’t manage to get around to talking much about [...]
Wii Feeds » Blog Archive » Be a Cake Hero // August 11, 2008 at 5:58 am |
[...] the maker a marriage proposal, but then, not all cakes are a Guitar Hero homage. Charm White made this cake last fall for her then-boyfriend’s birthday, but didn’t manage to get around to talking much about [...]
Be a Cake Hero | Your Game Blog // August 11, 2008 at 6:19 am |
[...] the maker a marriage proposal, but then, not all cakes are a Guitar Hero homage. Charm White made this cake last fall for her then-boyfriend’s birthday, but didn’t manage to get around to talking [...]
Guitar Hero Cake Tutorial — Sprite Stitch // August 11, 2008 at 7:01 am |
[...] I’m not charming (neither am I) wrote this interesting tutorial on how to make a realistic Guitar Hero cake. [...]
edinadevine // August 12, 2008 at 4:49 pm |
Fantastic cake!! My mouth is watering from the photos!
Congrats on the engagement!!! He’s a very lucky (and astute!) man.
Mirella // August 13, 2008 at 1:48 am |
Love the cake! I’ve been asked from a close friend of mine to make the same cake for her son’s b-day next month. Where/How did you get the templates for the cake? Any other suggestions/reccomendations would be appreciated.
Thank you.
imnotcharming // August 13, 2008 at 7:28 am |
Thanks for all the comments and links folks! Its been crazy how many of you are interested in seeing this cake!!!
Mirella, I made the template from an actual GH2 guitar. Good luck with your cake! Be sure to take photos!
/gamer » Blog Archive » Cool Stuff: The Best Guitar Hero Cake // August 13, 2008 at 5:11 pm |
[...] reading further on I couldn’t believe that someone spent the time to make it, just to eat it. Charmaine White is the creator of the cake. She spent well over a month just collecting ‘cake’ things [...]
Groom’s Cake Idea - Guitar Hero : One Red String // August 13, 2008 at 11:31 pm |
[...] Ok, who’s guy doesn’t like playing Guitar Hero?? This would make a fun groomsman cake and you can even bake it yourself with Nikkishell’s tutorial! [Link] [...]
подарок геймеру, торт для гика, тортик Guitar Hero, геймерские сладости, ручная работа, сделать торт своими руками, оригинальный торт, интересный // August 14, 2008 at 9:17 pm |
[...] сайте I’m Not Charming есть рецепт приготовления этого шедевра с картинками [...]
Internet Siao | Baking A Guitar Hero Cake // August 16, 2008 at 2:45 pm |
[...] guitar hero cake would definitely make any guitar hero fan a very happy person. ‘I’m Not Charming’ has come up with a tutorial for making this interesting cake for a birthday [...]
-=+fastlikesquirrel.com+=- » Blog Archive » GH cake tutorial // August 20, 2008 at 10:03 am |
[...] I’m not charming has written an excellent tutorial on how to create your own Guitar Hero themed cake – complete with whammy bar, and coloured fret buttons. [...]
crystal // August 22, 2008 at 2:00 am |
Hi! Adorable cake! What size sheet cake did you order? Wish me luck this weekend
this should be interesting!
migthegreek.com - Scraps - Awesome Guitar Hero Cake // October 8, 2008 at 10:54 pm |
[...] How the cake was made [...]
Larissa Meek » 26 Cakes Perfect for Geeks // January 13, 2009 at 1:01 am |
[...] I have yet to play Gutiar Hero but my guess is that I would be horrible at it because I have a bad ear for making music. I tried playing the violion in grade school and was always in the last chair. Anyway, if you want to make your own Gutiar Hero Cake, check out this detailed tutorial. [...]
amy // January 15, 2009 at 8:36 am |
Flippin’ awesome! I happen to have a boyfriend with a brithday coming up who would love it! How do I avoid the proposal though??
Aniversário de Geek | Geek&Blog // January 22, 2009 at 1:19 am |
[...] Fã do Guitar Hero detailed tutorial. [...]
MangoTangoBango // January 22, 2009 at 7:26 am |
hi there!
FREAKEN AWESOME CAKE!!!! I absolutely LOVES it!!!!
One question though… what size sheet cake did you order? It looks pretty big.
Lori // January 23, 2009 at 2:02 pm |
This is fantastic!!
The site and tutorial have inspired me to plan a surprise birthday party for my boyfriend with our little circle of friends. I was just wondering if you had a general list of all the “stuff” you had to get to make this. Being in college, knowing what to get ahead of time makes it easier and quicker to get finished
26 Cakes Perfect for Geeks « William book // February 8, 2009 at 9:56 pm |
[...] I have yet to play Gutiar Hero but my guess is that I would be horrible at it because I have a really bad ear for making music. I tried playing the violin in grade school and was always in the last chair. Anyway, if you want to make your own Guitar Hero Cake, check out this detailed tutorial. [...]
Emily // March 3, 2009 at 2:02 pm |
Thank God I came across this… I am making a guitar cake for my boyfriend whos birthday is at the end of the month. I think I’ll go with what you did… although I am very nervous… I’m not much of a baker!